Shaming offenders essay

Reintegrative shaming is the key to controlling crime Essay: Reintegrative shaming is the key to controlling crime If harsher punishments worked, arguably America would lead the world in crime reduction. But despite a prison population that doubled between and Christie, p. In fact, only one country in the world has actually managed to reduce their crime rate — that country is Japan, having also lowest per capita imprisonment rate in the world.

Shaming offenders essay

Shaming Penalties Essay Shaming Penalties Essay Shaming penalties involve the public humiliation of an individual who commits a crime or violates social norms, subjecting the offending individual to ridicule or disrespect by others in an attempt to punish and rehabilitate the individual.

Unlike incarceration, shaming does not employ a denial of liberty but rather a withdrawal of social status. This essay will review the history of shaming penalties and explore the arguments for and against the place of such penalties in the criminal justice system.

Most towns in colonial America had stocks or pillories in their public squares. Humans are social creatures, and the sense of self is dependent on the regard of others.

Through relationships with others, individuals construct a sense of self. The emotional and psychological pain caused by shaming can be extreme; it can even threaten the sense of personal identity.

Further, trials of criminals are open to the public and sometimes even broadcast on television; the resulting widespread media coverage of convicted criminals often serves as a form of public shaming, replacing the former physical stocks and pillories with virtual public squares. Drunk drivers have been ordered to display special license plates.

Public apologies, with advance notice to the media or through letters published in local papers, have also been ordered. Other forms of shaming include debasement of the offender by requiring involvement in a humiliating activity.

For example, a man convicted of domestic violence was required to endure his wife spitting in his face. The court specifically found that such public profession of his crime would emphasize to the offender the significance of that crime to his community and thus serve a rehabilitative, as well as a deterrent, purpose.

Criminal justice scholars have debated the usefulness of shaming penalties. Advantages of such penalties include the lower cost compared to incarceration and satisfaction of a need for community condemnation of a crime. Shaming penalties impose a similar type of moral condemnation as physically removing someone from society via imprisonment, and at a greatly reduced cost.

Crimes are considered to be not just offenses against a victim but are also offenses against society. Like other criminal penalties, shaming satisfies the needs of both victims and communities for retribution for, or compensation for the harm caused by, a crime; they reset a proper moral balance.

Finally, by exposing the offender to public view and by advertising his or her crime to the community, shaming may make the commission of similar crimes by the offender more difficult. Critics of shaming penalties argue that criminals are without consciences and therefore are incapable of being shamed.

Shaming offenders essay

Enduring public stigma also detracts from attempts to rehabilitate and reintegrate offenders into society. Individuals who have lost their sense of a respected place in society may be less motivated to attempt to regain such a place.

Essay: Reintegrative shaming is the key to controlling crime - Essay UK Free Essay Database

In fact, shaming may prompt some offenders to reject the norms of their society and become more committed to a criminal lifestyle. The active responsibility prompted by reintegrative shame in a restorative justice context is a productive contrast to the passive acceptance of punishment imposed by the traditional criminal justice system.

They seem to have the greatest deterrent and rehabilitative effects when offenders care about being respected by, and included in, such a community, and are allowed an avenue of regaining their former status as community members. Shaming may also be more effective when the emphasis is on evoking a sense of remorse for the harm caused to victims and to a community, rather than humiliating the offender, much like a restorative justice approach.

As the expense of incarceration becomes more of an economic burden on society, alternative sanctions such as shaming penalties will continue to be explored.

While the place of shaming penalties within the criminal justice system remains unclear, studying the questions surrounding shaming penalties may provide helpful guidance for shaping future punishment and rehabilitation strategies.

Crime, Shame and Reintegration. Cambridge University Press, If you need a custom essay or research paper on this topic please use our writing services.May 24,  · "Even the proponents of shaming punishment are leery of the consequences on innocent third parties," Markel observed.

convicted sex offenders have requested castration — chemical and actual. Does stigmatising offenders cause more harm than good? Discuss. In the study of deviant behaviour, sociologists have explored the effects of society’s perceptions on deviants in a school of thought popularly known as ‘Interactionism’.

This essay will review the history of shaming penalties and explore the arguments for and against the place of such penalties in the criminal justice system.

In fact, shaming may prompt some offenders to reject the norms of their society and become more committed to a criminal lifestyle. This free Criminology essay on Essay: Reintegrative shaming is the key to controlling crime is perfect for Criminology students to use as an example.

Offenders who experience disintegrative shaming in the US are, unsurprisingly, highly likely to recidivate and to become members of criminal or deviant subcultures.

This essay will review the history of shaming penalties and explore the arguments for and against the place of such penalties in the criminal justice system.

In fact, shaming may prompt some offenders to reject the norms of their society and become more committed to a criminal lifestyle. Pubic Shaming.

Words Nov 14th, Shaming Offenders Essay Words | 3 Pages.

Not what you're looking for?

Shaming Offenders The shaming of offenders has been in existence since the late 18th century. It was a form of corrections that was used to serve justice by offenders who had committed criminal acts. Offenders who had committed crimes against person or property.

Public Shame is Effective - Sample Essays